Did You Know There’s MoreTo Choosing Your Puppy Than Just Their Breed?
Understanding Whether You’re Getting a Working Line or Show Line Puppy is Crucial
Did you know that there is more to consider than just choosing the breed of puppy that you want? One thing you are definitely going to need to know is; are they working line, show line or a mixture of both? While both types are incredible in their individual ways, they tend to have very distinct differences. Understanding these and choosing your puppy accordingly can mean the difference between have the life you dream of with your dog…or not.
In a nutshell, a working line dog is like buying a Formula 1 car. They want to go fast and hard. A show line dog is your equivalent of an average Ford Fiesta. Nippy at times but generally quite steady.
Let’s look at this in more detail together.
What Are Working Line Dogs?
Working line dogs are bred for function over form. They come from a lineage specifically developed to excel in physical jobs such as herding, hunting, protection, search and rescue and other work-oriented tasks. Working line breeds typically have a very high drive, strong work ethic and high levels of physical stamina. In a pet home, these lines of dog require large amounts of mental stimulation on a daily basis. They won’t switch off at home as easily as your average dog. Sometimes, working line dogs who are not having their working needs met can struggle in a pet home. Some thrive of course, but they do generally require extra input from you.
Characteristics of Working Line Dogs
Whilst every dog is different of course, these are the most typical characteristics of working line dogs.
Energy and Drive: Working line dogs have a lot of energy and a strong desire to work. They thrive in environments where they can engage in physical activities like running, herding, protection work or putting their strong genetics (computer programming) into action. Without regular exercise and mental stimulation, these dogs can become bored and develop behavioural issues.
Temperament: These dogs are often a lot more intense and focused compared to show line dogs. They are quick learners, highly trainable and motivated by tasks or rewards. Working line dogs tend to be more independent and require regular training.
Appearance: Working line dogs tend to have a more functional appearance. They are usually leaner and more muscular than their show line counterparts. Their coats are usually designed to handle tough conditions.
Purpose: These dogs are ideal for active individuals, families or handlers who plan to engage them in work-like activities. They excel in sports like agility, obedience, scentwork and protection sports (depending on the breed) and they often thrive in working roles such as search and rescue and police work.
What Are Show Line Dogs?
Again, whilst all dogs are unique, these are the general characteristics of show line dogs.
Show line dogs are bred primarily for appearance, hopefully for health of the breed and to meet the breed standard established by organisations such as The Kennel Club UK. These dogs are often selected for their looks and temperament.
Characteristics of Show Line Dogs
Temperament: Show line dogs are bred to have a more relaxed and even temperament. They are often less driven than working line dogs making them better suited for families looking for a dog with an off-switch.
Appearance: Show line dogs are bred to have the ideal physical traits for their breed. They tend to have a more symmetrical appearance and may be larger and thicker set than working line dogs. Their appearance is a priority in breeding.
Energy Levels: While show line dogs still need exercise, mental stimulation and training, they typically have lower energy levels compared to working line dogs. They tend to have an off-switch and suit pet family homes well.
Purpose: Show line dogs are perfect for individuals or families who want a dog with a stable, predictable temperament who look like the breed standard. They may still excel in dog sports or training, but they are less likely to have the intense working drive found in working lines.
Key Differences Between Working Line and Show Line Dogs
Purpose of Breeding:
Working Line: performance, stamina, work ethic and ability to do specific jobs (and hopefully health of the breed).
Show Line: appearance, temperament and adherence to breed standards (and hopefully health of the breed).
Energy Levels:
Working Line: Very high energy. Needs significant physical and mental stimulation daily.
Show Line: Moderate energy levels, often content with regular exercise and play but less intense than working line dogs.
Appearance:
Working Line: Practical appearance, often leaner.
Show Line: Aesthetic is key in keeping up with breed standards.
Temperament:
Working Line: Focused, driven and more independent.
Show Line: Even-tempered, often more relaxed and sociable; easier for most families to manage.
Exercise Needs:
Working Line: Needs intense daily exercise, mental challenges and jobs to do.
Show Line: Requires regular exercise but can be satisfied with less intense physical activity.
How to Choose Between a Working Line and Show Line Dog
When choosing between a working line and a show line puppy, consider the following questions:
What Is Your Lifestyle?
Are you an active person who enjoys running, hiking or engaging in dog sports? Will you be prepared to cater to your dog’s needs in terms of their genetics and need for increased mental stimulation? If so, a working line dog might be the right fit for you.
Do you have a more relaxed lifestyle and want a dog that can keep up but doesn’t require intense physical activity? A show line dog may be a better match.
Do You Have Time for Training?
Working line dogs need consistent training and mental stimulation to stay happy and well-behaved. If you have the time and commitment to dedicate to training, a working line dog can be a rewarding challenge.
Show line dogs typically require less intensive training and can be a good choice for first-time dog owners or those with busier schedules.
What Are Your Expectations for Your Dog?
If you want a dog to compete in dog sports, work in a specific role (like protection or herding) or hike for miles and miles with you, a working line dog will likely be a better fit.
If your primary goal is to have a beautiful, all-rounded family dog, a show line dog may be a more suitable choice.
Do You Have Experience Handling High-Drive Dogs?
Working line dogs often need experienced owners who can provide structure, boundaries and adequate outlets for their energy. Of course, that is not always the case and some first-time dog owners do very well with a working line dog. I would strongly recommend you start training early with a professional if you choose a working line dog.
Show line dogs are generally easier for novice dog owners to manage given their less intense temperament.
What’s Your Grooming Preference?
Working line dogs tend to have lower-maintenance coats that are better suited for outdoor activities.
Show line dogs often require more grooming and maintenance to keep up their appearance.
Choosing between a working line and a show line dog ultimately comes down to your lifestyle, experience level and what you want out of your relationship with your dog.
If you’re an active, experienced dog owner looking for a dog to adventure or work with, a working line dog may be the perfect fit. If you’re looking for a beautiful, even-tempered dog who will likely fit a family lifestyle better, a show line dog is more likely what you’re looking for.
Whichever you choose, remember that each dog is an individual. With the right lifestyle, training, care and love, all of them should thrive. Knowing what you’re getting over and above the fundamental breed of your dog is absolutely essential in making the right choice of puppy for you.
Need help with training your puppy? Head to the link below to get in touch.
This document and its contents is copyright of Progressive Dog Company Limited - ©ProgDog – all rights reserved. Any redistribution or reproduction of part or all of the contents in any form is prohibited.
